China Perspectives 139
SPECIAL FEATURE 2024
China’s borderlands: From Getaway to Gateway
- Special Feature
- Article
- Book Reviews
Editorial - Reframing China Studies: Insights from the Margins and Global Intersections of China’s Borderlands
Multi-sited Consumption in the Greater Bay Area: The Interplay of National Policies, Consumer Behaviours, and Urban Amenity Transformation
ABSTRACT: This study examines the phenomenon of multi-sited consumption within the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area (GBA) and investigates the interplay of national policies, individual consumer behaviours, and the evolving urban landscape in this region by proposing the analytical concepts of multi-sited consumption and urban cluster amenities. Drawing on qualitative interviews and secondary data, this research finds that macro-level efforts, such as regional economic integration, improved infrastructure, and streamlined border controls, increase cross-border mobilities which facilitate multi-sited consumption. Moreover, driven by the desires for cost-effectiveness, scarcity, and uniqueness, GBA residents increasingly engage in multi-sited consumption. Lastly, we find that the interactions between macro-level strategies and aggregated micro-level consumer behaviours have led to meso-level transformations, such as the redistribution and specialisation of urban cluster amenities across the GBA. These findings offer insights into the recent and ongoing shifting urban hierarchies in the GBA and highlight the broader implications of multi-sited consumption for regional economic integration.
KEYWORDS: Greater Bay Area, multi-sited consumption, urban cluster amenities, cross-border mobility, regional integration.
The Making of Border Infrastructures: Evolution and Interaction with Cross-border Migration on the China–Myanmar Border
ABSTRACT: This paper explores the evolution of border infrastructures along the China–Myanmar border, with a focus on the city of Ruili. It traces the historical development of these infrastructures, from their minimal military presence to early market-driven functions, and eventually to the growing emphasis on security. The study highlights the interaction between shifting institutional logics, economic growth, national security, and geopolitical strategy, and the continued resilience of cross-border migration. Despite increased restrictions and security measures, migration flows have remained persistent, driven by economic, familial, and cultural ties. Drawing on extensive fieldwork, in-depth interviews with various stakeholders, and archival data, this paper examines how infrastructure has shaped, and been shaped by, state policy, local actors, and even non-state actors. The research demonstrates that border infrastructure is not a static entity but a dynamic system influenced by multilevel governance and the competing interests of various stakeholders. This paper argues that while the central government’s shift towards security-centric infrastructure has transformed the border region, market-driven logic and migration networks continue to exert significant influence. The study offers insights into the future trajectory of border governance in an era of increasing geopolitical tension and examines how the cumulative effects of these infrastructures impact social, economic, and political outcomes in the China–Myanmar borderlands.
KEYWORDS: border infrastructure, institutional logic, cumulative causation, China–Myanmar border, Belt and Road Initiative.
Negotiating Territorial Restructuring in Chinese Borderland Margins: The Viewpoints of Residents of Nujiang, Yunnan
ABSTRACT: This article focuses on the study of Chinese territorial dynamics produced by the relation between government actors and residents of a southwestern borderland margin. As state policies aim to further integrate remote borderland margins to national territory through modernisation or poverty alleviation development projects, residents live through fast-paced territorial restructuring that bears the risk of social conflicts. To explore the construction of borderland margins as territories, this article studies power relations emerging from integration policies. It draws on a geopolitical approach focused on the study of local protests. From the case study of the Nujiang River Valley (Yunnan), it finds that resident agency to protest can result in the adaptation of government-led territory building.
KEYWORDS: borderland, China, geopolitics, margin, protests, resident, territorial restructuring, spatial planning, territory, Yunnan.
The Dao of Happiness in Contemporary China: On the Encompassing Meanings and Affects of “Xingfu”
ABSTRACT: The notion of happiness has been extended in recent decades from a quality of well-being to a value-laden concept employed in political campaigns, development plans, commercial advertising, and transnational psychology. In China, the term xingfu has extended through this tendency, articulated as an equivalent of deep-seated individualised “happiness,” while also carrying elements of livelihood and social welfare. Drawing on fieldwork in psychological workshops and diverse academic and political texts, this article conceptualises the semiotic and communicative attributes of xingfu in Chinese society today. I define xingfu as a contemporary dao, in the sense that it emerges as a consensual priority that alludes to seeming universal humanity, which may be employed to validate other political agendas, while it also activates diverse interactions and imaginaries that extend beyond preexisting or fixed priorities.
KEYWORDS: happiness, xingfu, China, positive psychology, Xi Jinping, Sara Ahmed, self-improvement.
Different Privileges, Divergent Paths: Income Loss Among Administrative Elites and Market Elites in China During Covid-19
ABSTRACT: Covid-19 has affected everyone in China, but not equally. Previous studies have mostly focused on the more severe income loss experienced by socio-economically disadvantaged groups during the pandemic, ignoring income disparities within elite groups. Using data from the 2021 Chinese General Social Survey, this paper finds that administrative elites experienced relatively less income loss during the pandemic, while market elites faced more severe losses, even exceeding those of the non-elite group. The disparity between the two elite groups in their resilience to income risk, represented by the type of pay, is an important mechanism behind their divergence in income loss. Additionally, in regions where the redistribution system was further strengthened, the income losses of administrative elites decreased further, while in areas with more severe market closures, the income losses of market elites increased further. This study enhances our understanding of the heterogeneity within China’s elites and the tension between the market system and the redistribution system in contemporary China.
KEYWORDS: Covid-19, China, administrative elites, market elites, income loss.
New Agricultural Operators and the Local Politics of Land Transfer in China
ABSTRACT: Existing studies have shown how, under the policy agenda of agricultural modernisation, the Chinese government has promoted the large-scale transfer of rural land from smallholders to new agricultural operators (NAOs) such as agribusinesses, family farms, and professional cooperatives. Despite this national trend, there are important local variations in the extent and dynamics of land transfer, a topic that has remained underexplored in the literature. Using multiple-case methodology, this paper compares three cases of land transfer in a rural township in Shandong Province to examine how and why patterns of land transfer and management differ. Drawing on in-depth fieldwork and interviews, we reveal how trajectories of land transfer and agrarian transition are shaped by the different background and strategies of individual NAOs, which in turn structure the land and labour arrangements at each locality and give rise to distinct dynamics of interactions between the state, NAOs, and local communities. Our findings highlight the need to go beyond national statistics to explore the local politics of land transfer as well as the agency of NAOs in shaping diverse trajectories of agrarian transition.
KEYWORDS: land transfer, new agricultural operators (NAOs), local politics, agrarian transition, agricultural modernisation, Shandong Province, rural China.
Defining Chineseness in Chinese Infrastructure Projects in Africa: The Case of Ghana
ABSTRACT: This paper discusses and conceptualises the notion of Chineseness as related to infrastructure projects in Ghana and Africa more generally. Based on fieldwork in Ghana and secondary literature, our study combines two aspects. On the one hand, we undertake a nationality and origin-based analysis of all the elements (ownership, financing, design, consulting, construction standards, materials and equipment, labour practices) making up Chinese infrastructure projects in Ghana. On the other hand, we include perceptions of such projects as Chinese. Our analysis identifies different degrees of Chineseness in Ghana’s infrastructure projects, what we also describe as “diluted Chineseness.” We find that even projects perceived as “fully Chinese” are populated by other international and local actors. Our study further reveals how portrayals of such infrastructure projects as “fully Chinese” are used by different actors to push different agendas – at times expressing opposite views about the Chinese presence in Africa.
KEYWORDS: Chineseness, Ghana, Africa, China, Chinese companies, infrastructure projects.
KUZUOĞLU, Uluğ. 2024. Codes of Modernity: Chinese Scripts in the Global Information Age. New York: Columbia University Press.
LO, Ming-Cheng M., Yu-Yueh TSAI, and Michael Shiyung LIU (eds.). 2024. Taiwan’s COVID-19 Experience: Governance, Governmentality, and the Global Pandemic. London: Routledge.
FU, Po-Shek. 2023. Hong Kong Media and Asia’s Cold War. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
CHIN, Angelina Y. 2023. Unsettling Exiles: Chinese Migrants in Hong Kong and the Southern Periphery during the Cold War. New York: Columbia University Press.
BECKERSHOFF, André. 2023. Social Forces in the Re-making of Cross-strait Relations: Hegemony and Social Movements in Taiwan. London: Routledge.
CHEUNG, Sidney C. H. 2022. Hong Kong Foodways. Hong Kong: Hong Kong University Press.